Battle of Fuel Generators: Westinghouse Igen4500DF vs Duromax xp4500ih

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Comparison of Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 Generators
   1. Size and Features Comparison
   2. Power Comparison
   3. Runtime Comparison
   4. Noise Level Comparison
   5. Propane Conversion Comparison
   6. Remote Start Comparison
   7. Amps and Voltage Comparison
   8. Load Handling Comparison
3. Pros and Cons of Westinghouse 4500
4. Pros and Cons of Duramax 4500
5. Conclusion

Comparison of Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 Generators

When it comes to choosing a generator, the Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 are two popular options that many people consider. In this article, we will compare these two generators and explore their features, performance, and other factors to help you make an informed decision.

Size and Features Comparison

Starting with the size and features, both the Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 are dual fuel generators. However, there are some differences in their dimensions. The Westinghouse generator is slightly bigger, longer, and taller compared to the Duramax generator. It also appears to be thicker. Both generators come with a carrying handle and 5.5-inch wheels for easy portability. While the Duramax has a slightly larger handle, the Westinghouse handle is positioned lower, making it a bit more challenging to lift and pull.

In terms of display and controls, the Duramax generator has a more user-friendly interface. It features a clear display with a fuel gauge, ammeter, voltage indicator, power meter, and frequency display, all conveniently located upfront. On the other hand, the Westinghouse generator also has similar features but requires toggling through them using a small button. The display on the Westinghouse generator is not as clear and easy to read as the Duramax.

Power Comparison

When it comes to power, both the Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 generators have similar running wattage. The Westinghouse generator offers 3700 watts running, while the Duramax generator provides 3600 watts running. However, the Westinghouse generator has a slightly higher peak wattage of 4500 compared to the Duramax's 4500 peak watts. While these differences may not be significant, they should be considered based on your specific power needs.

Runtime Comparison

In terms of runtime, both generators provide long-lasting power. The Westinghouse generator offers 18 hours of running time on fuel, while the Duramax generator provides 16 hours. However, when running on propane, both generators offer the same impressive runtime of 22 hours. This means you can rely on either generator for extended periods without worrying about refueling.

Noise Level Comparison

When it comes to noise level, the Duramax generator performs slightly better than the Westinghouse generator. The Duramax operates at around 52 decibels, while the Westinghouse operates at around 65 decibels. This difference may be noticeable if you prioritize quieter operation, especially in noise-sensitive environments.

Propane Conversion Comparison

Both the Westinghouse and Duramax generators offer the convenience of dual fuel usage. However, there are differences in their propane connection methods. The Westinghouse generator has a screw-on type connection, while the Duramax generator has a switch for easy switching between propane and gas. Some users prefer the quick connect feature, which the Duramax generator lacks.

Remote Start Comparison

When it comes to remote start capabilities, the Duramax generator comes out on top. It is equipped with two wireless remotes, allowing you to start and stop the generator from a distance. On the other hand, the Westinghouse generator only provides one remote. The ability to start the generator remotely can be especially convenient, saving you time and effort.

Amps and Voltage Comparison

In terms of amps and voltage, both generators have similar capabilities. The Duramax generator provides 30 amps running, while the Westinghouse generator offers 30.7 amps. These values are close enough that it would not significantly impact your power usage. Additionally, both generators provide reliable voltage output, ensuring stable power delivery to your devices.

Load Handling Comparison

To test the load handling abilities of these generators, we conducted a test by hooking them up to an RV and simulating typical loads. Both generators performed well and were able to handle the load of multiple appliances, including refrigerators and air conditioners. However, the Duramax generator demonstrated better load handling capabilities and maintained stable voltage even under heavy load. The Westinghouse generator came close but experienced a slight drop in voltage. Nevertheless, both generators performed admirably under normal RV load conditions.

Pros and Cons of Westinghouse 4500

• Pros:

  • Slightly higher peak wattage compared to Duramax
  • Reliable power output
  • Longer runtime on fuel
  • Clear and informative display
  • Remote start capability

• Cons:

  • Higher noise level
  • Inconvenient propane connection method
  • One remote compared to Duramax's two remotes

Pros and Cons of Duramax 4500

• Pros:

  • Quieter operation
  • More convenient propane switching
  • Two wireless remotes for remote start
  • Better load handling performance
  • Lower weight compared to Westinghouse

• Cons:

  • Slightly lower peak wattage compared to Westinghouse
  • Slightly shorter runtime on fuel

Conclusion

Both the Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 generators have their strengths and weaknesses. The choice between them ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you value higher peak wattage, longer runtime on fuel, and a clear display, the Westinghouse generator may be the better option for you. However, if you prioritize quieter operation, convenient propane switching, better load handling, and the convenience of two remotes, the Duramax generator could be the right choice. Consider your power requirements, noise preferences, and other factors before making a decision.

Highlights

• The Westinghouse 4500 and Duramax 4500 are popular dual fuel generators.
• The Duramax generator has a slightly higher peak wattage, while the Westinghouse generator offers longer runtime on fuel.
• The Duramax generator operates at a lower noise level compared to the Westinghouse generator.
• The Westinghouse generator has a screw-on propane connection, while the Duramax generator has a propane switch for easy switching.
• The Duramax generator comes with two wireless remotes, allowing for convenient remote start.
• Both generators have similar amps and voltage capabilities but differ in load handling performance.
• Consider factors such as power requirements, noise preferences, and convenience features before choosing between these generators.

FAQs

Q: Can the Duramax and Westinghouse generators be used in noise-sensitive environments?

A: While both generators are relatively quiet, the Duramax operates at a lower noise level, making it more suitable for noise-sensitive environments.

Q: Can the Westinghouse generator be easily converted from propane to gas?

A: Yes, the Westinghouse generator has a switch for easy conversion from propane to gas and vice versa.

Q: Does the Duramax generator have a quick connect feature for propane?

A: Unfortunately, the Duramax generator does not have a quick connect feature for propane; it uses a screw-on type connection.

Q: How many wireless remotes are included with the Westinghouse and Duramax generators?

A: The Westinghouse generator comes with one remote, while the Duramax generator includes two wireless remotes for convenient remote start.

Q: Which generator is better at handling heavy loads?

A: The Duramax generator demonstrated better load handling capabilities and maintained stable voltage even under heavy load compared to the Westinghouse generator.