Portable Oxygen Concentrator Comparison: Inogen G5 vs Philips vs Oxymed P2

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Comparison of Weight
3. Battery Backup
4. Price Comparison
5. Warranty and Battery Price
6. Flow Output
7. Trigger Sensitivity
8. Service and Repair
9. Verdict
10. Conclusion

Introduction

Portable oxygen concentrators are essential medical devices for respiratory patients in India. In this article, we will compare three of the best battery-powered concentrators available in the market: Inogen One G5, Oxymed P2, and Phillips SimplyGo Mini. We will explore various factors such as weight, battery backup, price, warranty, flow output, trigger sensitivity, and service and repair options. By the end of this article, you will have a clear understanding of which concentrator suits your needs best.

Comparison of Weight

Weight is a crucial factor for respiratory patients as a heavy machine can cause breathing difficulties. Among the three concentrators, the Oxymed P2 is the lightest, weighing only 1.98 kg with the battery. The Inogen One G5 weighs slightly more at 2.6 kg, while the Phillips SimplyGo Mini is 2.7 kg. The Oxymed P2's lightweight design makes it a convenient choice for those who prioritize mobility and ease of use.

Battery Backup

The battery backup of a portable oxygen concentrator depends on the flow settings. Higher flow settings result in lower battery backup as the device drains faster. In terms of battery backup, the Inogen One G5 offers the longest duration, providing up to 13 hours on a pulse setting of 1 and around 3 hours at the maximum flow of 6. Oxymed provides a backup of up to 10 hours, while Phillips offers up to 12 hours. Patients requiring extended periods of oxygen therapy can benefit from the Inogen One G5's exceptional battery life.

Price Comparison

Price is an important consideration while purchasing a portable oxygen concentrator. The Oxymed P2 is priced at around 1,48,000 Rupees on Amazon, making it the most affordable option among the three. The Phillips SimplyGo Mini is priced at around 2,20,000 Rupees, while the Inogen One G5 costs around 2,50,000 Rupees. It is advisable to check oxygentimes.com for better prices and exclusive offers on these devices.

Warranty and Battery Price

Warranty and battery price are significant factors to consider when buying a portable oxygen concentrator. The Inogen and Phillips SimplyGo Mini come with a 2-year warranty, whereas Oxymed offers a longer warranty period of 3 years. However, the battery warranty differs among the brands. Phillips provides a 3-month warranty, Inogen offers a 6-month warranty, and Oxymed provides a 1-year warranty on the battery. It is crucial to keep in mind the warranty duration and battery price while making a purchase decision. Oxymed stands out with its lower-priced battery options, making it more affordable for patients who require multiple spare batteries.

Flow Output

Flow output determines the amount of oxygen delivered by the concentrator. Both the Oxymed and Phillips SimplyGo Mini offer an output of up to 5 pulse settings, equivalent to 3 liters per minute of continuous flow. In contrast, the Inogen One G5 provides a flow of up to 6 pulse settings, equivalent to 3.8 liters per minute of continuous flow. The Inogen One G5's higher flow capacity makes it suitable for patients with higher oxygen requirements.

Trigger Sensitivity

Trigger sensitivity is an essential factor for pulse flow portable oxygen concentrators. It determines how sensitive the device is towards detecting inspirations. Inogen and Oxymed have a trigger sensitivity of 0.12cm H2O, while Phillips offers a slightly lower sensitivity of 0.20cm H2O. The trigger sensitivity affects the accuracy of oxygen delivery, and patients should consider their breathing patterns and needs when choosing a concentrator.

Service and Repair

When it comes to service and repair options, Oxymed stands out as the only brand in India that provides home service throughout the country. On the other hand, both Phillips and Inogen require patients to take the machine to their service centers themselves, which are only available in major cities. Oxymed's extensive reach across India ensures prompt and convenient servicing for customers.

Verdict

In terms of quality and performance, Oxymed can be compared to Maruti in the automobile industry. It offers excellent service network, great value for money, and high-quality standards with certifications like CE and FDA. Philips is comparable to Honda, providing decent specs, sleek design, and a touch screen display. However, the touch screen convenience can be superior on Oxymed and Inogen concentrators, especially for older patients. Inogen can be likened to Mercedes, offering the best specs without any compromise. It excels in flow rate, battery life, and user-replaceable sieve beds. However, the long-term service and spare part costs of Inogen can be higher. Ultimately, the choice depends on individual requirements, affordability, and trust in the brand. Oxymed P2 is the best option for those seeking an affordable range, while Inogen One G5 is a premium choice for those willing to invest in advanced features.

Conclusion

Portable oxygen concentrators have revolutionized the lives of respiratory patients in India. In this article, we compared the Inogen One G5, Oxymed P2, and Phillips SimplyGo Mini in terms of weight, battery backup, price, warranty, flow output, trigger sensitivity, and service options. Each brand offers its unique advantages, and patients should consider their priorities while making a purchase decision. Remember to explore reputed websites like oxygentimes.com for better prices and comprehensive information on portable oxygen concentrators.